Keeping the family home is one of the most emotionally loaded decisions in a divorce. And it’s also one of the most financially risky ones if you’re not looking at the full picture.
The house means something. It’s where the kids grew up, where you built your life. That’s real. But emotion and financial logic don’t always point in the same direction, and in divorce, conflating the two can cost you.
Before you decide that keeping the house is what you want, here’s the math you need to sit with.
How Colorado Divides the Family Home
Colorado is an equitable distribution state. That means marital property is divided fairly, not necessarily equally. The family home, if purchased during the marriage, is marital property, which means both spouses have a claim to its equity regardless of whose name is on the mortgage.
Equity, not the house itself, is what gets divided. If your home is worth $550,000 and you owe $250,000 on it, you have $300,000 in equity. In a typical Colorado divorce, both spouses have a stake in that $300,000.
If you want to keep the house, you generally have two options: buy out your spouse’s share of the equity, or offset it with other marital assets (retirement accounts, savings, investments). Both of those paths require honest numbers.
The Buyout Question
A buyout means refinancing the mortgage in your name alone and paying your spouse their share of the equity. In Northern Colorado right now, that’s not a small number.
Fort Collins median home prices are holding around $550,000 to $585,000 depending on the source and the month. If you bought several years ago and have built equity, a buyout could mean coming up with $100,000, $150,000, or more. That’s money coming out of other assets, or it’s a larger mortgage on a single income.
Then there’s the refinance itself. Current mortgage rates in Colorado are running between 6.4% and 6.9%. If you and your spouse locked in a rate at 3% four years ago, refinancing to keep the house means your monthly payment goes up significantly, sometimes by hundreds of dollars a month, on income that’s now supporting one household instead of two.
Run that number before you commit. A CDFA, a Certified Divorce Financial Analyst, can model this out with you so you’re making the decision based on actual cash flow, not hope.
What Keeping the House Actually Costs
The mortgage is one line item. The full cost of homeownership is several.
Property taxes, insurance, maintenance, HOA fees if applicable, and the ongoing costs of a house that was likely sized for two adults are all real. In Colorado, homeowner’s insurance costs have climbed sharply over the past decade, driven by hail and wildfire risk. The average annual premium in Colorado is now around $4,100, more than double what it was ten years ago.
Add that to a refinanced mortgage at current rates, and the question becomes: can you afford this house, on your income, without the financial strain undermining the stability you were trying to preserve for your kids?
Stability for children comes from their parents being financially stable. A house that stretches you to the breaking point doesn’t deliver that.
The Tax Picture
There’s one financial argument for selling the house together rather than one spouse keeping it, and it has to do with capital gains.
When you sell a primary residence, federal law allows you to exclude up to $250,000 in capital gains if you’re single, or $500,000 if you’re married filing jointly, provided you’ve lived in the home for at least two of the past five years. If you sell during the divorce process while you’re still married, you may preserve access to that larger exclusion.
If you keep the house and sell later as a single person, you’re limited to $250,000. On a Colorado home with significant appreciation, that difference is worth real money.
This isn’t a reason to sell if keeping the house makes sense for your situation. But it’s a factor worth putting on the table, and your CDFA or tax advisor can help you model the difference.
When Keeping the House Does Make Sense
There are situations where keeping the house is genuinely the right call. If the kids are close to finishing school and disrupting that isn’t worth it, if you have the income to carry the mortgage comfortably, if there’s equity you can trade against other assets without a cash buyout, or if the mortgage rate is low enough that refinancing still pencils out, keeping the house can work.
The key word is comfortably. Not barely. Not by cutting everything else. Comfortably.
The goal of a divorce settlement is to set both people up for a stable next chapter. A house that looks like security but functions like a financial trap undermines that, sometimes for years.
The Conversation Worth Having
Most people walk into divorce with a position on the house before they’ve looked at the numbers. I get it. The house feels like the thing. But the best decisions come from getting the full picture first.
In mediation, we work through the financial realities of both paths, keeping and selling, so you and your spouse can make an informed choice that works for both of you without leaving one person holding an asset they can’t sustain.
Our team includes Katie Janda, a Certified Divorce Financial Analyst, who works with clients specifically on the financial side of these decisions. If you want to think through the house question before you’ve committed to a direction, a free consultation is a good place to start. You can book one at openspacemediation.com.
If you’re navigating this right now and want to understand what your options actually look like, book a free consultation here.
Open Space Mediation serves Colorado couples seeking a dignified, cost-effective path through divorce. Liz Merrill is a professional mediator, not an attorney, and this post does not constitute legal advice.
0 Comments